Tuesday, July 30, 2024
Scale in Pipelines 101 – Part 1
Scale. This sneaky accumulation of mineral deposits can cause major disruptions to operations. But what exactly is scale?
Q2 Technologies Team
Experts in H2S Scavenging Solutions
With decades of combined experience, the Q2 Technologies team specializes in innovative hydrogen sulfide (H2S) scavenging solutions for the oil and gas, wastewater treatment, and industrial sectors.
Read more blogs from this series:
Imagine a bustling oil field, where crude oil, natural gas, and produced water are constantly moving through a network of pipelines. Everything seems to be running smoothly until one day, the flow starts to slow down, and equipment begins to malfunction. The cause? Scale. This sneaky accumulation of mineral deposits can cause major disruptions to operations. But what exactly is scale? How does it form, and what types are there? More importantly, how can it be treated or even prevented?
Scale formation at a pipeline facility, causing significant downtime and increase in maintenance expenditures. Scale formation can happen along many parts of a system. Continue reading to learn more!
What is Scale?
To start, scale is the accumulation of mineral deposits that form when incompatible water sources and dissolved minerals come into contact. This usually happens under ideal conditions on the surfaces of pipes and other equipment in oil and natural gas operations. Scale can appear early in the production cycle, near the wellhead or at a tank battery, and can migrate downstream, affecting midstream facilities and terminal stations.
Why is scale a concern?
All scales have the potential to cause massive operational and safety issues in the oil field, such as:
- Reduced efficiency of equipment
- Decreased flow rates
- Potential line breaks and serious damage
While maintenance requires attention and resources, the unchecked impact of scale formation can result in significant financial losses.
How is scale formed?
Scale forms when water mixed with minerals creates solid deposits. In oil fields, this typically involves:
- Formation water: Water that is naturally present in the production horizon of oil-bearing and natural gas reserves.
- Injection water: Water and components injected into the formation to stimulate oil and gas production.
When these two types of incompatible water mix, the minerals can react and form solid deposits on the surfaces of pipes and other equipment.
A more detailed process of the reaction is illustrated here:
Common types of Scale
Calcium Carbonate (CaCO3):
- Formation: Calcium ions combine with carbonate ions in water.
- Contributing Factors: High pH levels, high temperatures, pressure changes.
- Removal: Treated with hydrochloric acid or organic acids.
- Example: Limescale on faucets in areas with high mineral content.
- Appearance: Typically white and chalky.
Calcium Sulfate (CaCO4):
- Formation: Reaction of calcium and sulfate ions, forming gypsum at temperatures below 200°F.
- Contributing Factors: High concentration of calcium and sulfate ions.
- Removal: Mechanical removal or acid treatment.
- Example: Found in reservoirs with high sulfate ion concentration.
- Appearance: Needle-shaped structure.
How can you tell the difference between CaCO3 and CaSO4?
CaCO3, or calcium carbonate, has a spiral growth and precipitates in the form of calcite. In contrast, CaSO4, or calcium sulfate, precipitates in the form of gypsum and has a needle-shaped structure.
Naica Crystal Cave, a real mine in Chihuahua, Mexico has produced giant calcium sulfate scale, aka gypsum. Gypsum can form in pipelines in a similar chaotic structure albeit a lot smaller if the conditions are right.
Barium Sulfate (BaSO4) Scale:
- Formation: Barium ions in produced water react with sulfate ions.
- Contributing Factors: High concentrations of barium and sulfate ions, temperature, pressure, and pH changes.
- Removal: Difficult to remove; typically requires mechanical milling or specialized chemical treatments.
- Example: Prevalent in high-barium reservoirs.
- Appearance: Grayish, may have a blackish appearance due to impurities.
Strontium Sulfate (SrSO4) Scale:
- Formation: Strontium ions react with sulfate ions in produced water.
- Contributing Factors: Similar conditions to barium sulfate scale.
- Removal: Mechanical milling or chemical treatments.
- Example: Often found alongside barium sulfate scale.
- Appearance: Similar to barium sulfate, with a crystalline structure.
Iron Sulfide (FeS) Scale:
- Formation: Iron ions combine with sulfide ions, often in anaerobic conditions with sulfate-reducing bacteria.
- Contributing Factors: Corrosion, presence of sulfate-reducing bacteria.
- Removal: Chemical treatment, mechanical removal.
- Example: Found in pipelines prone to corrosion.
- Appearance: Dark, often black, resembling pyrite or Fool’s Gold.
Hydrate Scale:
- Formation: Solid crystalline compounds formed by water and gases like methane under specific temperature and pressure conditions.
- Contributing Factors: Low temperatures, high pressures in natural gas pipelines.
- Removal: Temperature and pressure adjustments, chemical inhibitors.
- Example: Blockages in natural gas pipelines.
- Appearance: Ice-like crystalline structure.
Asphaltene Scale:
- Formation: Precipitation of heavy hydrocarbons known as asphaltenes from crude oil.
- Contributing Factors: Changes in temperature, pressure, and composition.
- Removal: Solvent treatments, mechanical removal.
- Example: Found in crude oil pipelines.
- Appearance: Dark, tar-like deposits.
Silica Scale:
- Formation: Precipitation of dissolved silica in produced water.
- Contributing Factors: Temperature and pressure changes.
- Removal: Mechanical removal, chemical treatments.
- Example: Common in geothermal and some oilfield waters.
- Appearance: Hard, glassy deposits.
Paraffin Wax:
- Formation: Precipitates out of crude oil as it cools, aiding the formation of other scales.
- Contributing Factors: Lower temperatures in pipelines.
- Removal: Mechanical scraping, chemical solvents.
- Example: Common in crude oil pipelines exposed to cold environments.
- Appearance: Waxy, white or yellowish deposits.
Most scales encountered in the oil field are mixtures of two or more types. And as if that wasn’t enough, many other solids can be found in deposits, originating from the formation itself, completion materials, corrosion byproducts, and chemicals added during production or stimulation. In fact, ASTM lists over 120 different possible materials that can be found in water-formed deposits.
Understanding the basics of scale formation is just the beginning. In the next part of our series, we’ll explore the specific causes and detailed prevention and treatment strategies for scale in pipelines. Don’t miss Part 2 to learn more about how to keep your operations running smoothly and efficiently.
Continue to part 2.
FAQs
The most common types of scale in pipelines include:
– Calcium Carbonate (CaCO₃): Forms when calcium ions combine with carbonate ions, often due to high pH levels, elevated temperatures, or pressure changes.
– Calcium Sulfate (CaSO₄): Develops from the reaction of calcium and sulfate ions, forming gypsum at temperatures below 200°F.
– Barium Sulfate (BaSO₄): Occurs when barium ions in produced water react with sulfate ions, leading to deposits that are notably challenging to remove due to their low solubility.
– Strontium Sulfate (SrSO₄): Forms similarly to barium sulfate and often coexists with it.
– Iron Sulfide (FeS): Results from the combination of iron ions with sulfide ions, frequently under anaerobic conditions facilitated by sulfate-reducing bacteria.
– Hydrate Scale: Solid crystalline compounds formed by water and gases like methane under specific temperature and pressure conditions.
– Asphaltene Scale: Precipitation of heavy hydrocarbons known as asphaltenes from crude oil.
– Silica Scale: Precipitation of dissolved silica in produced water.
– Paraffin Wax: Precipitates out of crude oil as it cools, aiding the formation of other scales.
These scales can form individually or as mixtures, complicating removal efforts.
Scale deposits can lead to:
– Reduced Flow Rates: Accumulation narrows the pipeline’s internal diameter, hindering fluid movement.
– Equipment Malfunction: Deposits on equipment surfaces can impair functionality, leading to increased wear and potential failures.
– Increased Pressure: Blockages necessitate higher operational pressures to maintain flow rates, stressing infrastructure.
– Corrosion Under Deposits: Scale can create crevices that promote localized corrosion, compromising pipeline integrity.
Collectively, these issues can cause significant operational disruptions and financial losses.
Barium Sulfate (BaSO₄):
– Mechanical Removal: Techniques like milling or jetting physically break down deposits.
– Chemical Treatment: Specialized chelating agents or acids are used, though BaSO₄’s low solubility makes this challenging.
Iron Sulfide (FeS):
– Chemical Dissolution: Acids, such as hydrochloric acid, can dissolve FeS, but care is needed to manage potential release of toxic gases.
– Mechanical Methods: Techniques like scraping or pigging can be employed, especially for hard scales.
The choice of method depends on scale composition, location, and operational considerations.
Scale can form at various stages, including:
– Near the Wellhead: Early in production, especially when formation and injection waters mix.
– Within Pipelines: As fluids are transported, changes in temperature, pressure, or chemical composition can induce scaling.
– Processing Facilities: Equipment like separators and heat exchangers are prone to deposits due to operational conditions.
Understanding these stages is crucial for implementing effective monitoring and prevention strategies.
Implementing regular monitoring and maintenance protocols is essential to mitigate the adverse effects of scale formation in oil and gas operations.
Related Articles
HOW CAN WE HELP?
Have a question? Need a quote? Our technical staff is here to help you identify the right solution for your project requirements.